LA District Attorney Investigating Fake Email Allegation | Khubesrian Condemns Cyber Bullying

The city councilmember gave an emotional response during Wednesday's meeting, to what she considers bullying in the wake of new allegations against her regarding supposedly fraudulent e-mails sent

The City of South Pasadena on Monday asked the LA District Attorney’s Public Integrity Division to review a citizen complaint that District 2 Councilmember Marina Khubesrian “used fictitious email accounts to threaten a colleague and wrote false public comments at a previous city council meeting.”

The City of South Pasadena on Monday asked the LA District Attorney’s Public Integrity Division to review a citizen complaint that District 2 Councilmember Marina Khubesrian “used fictitious email accounts to threaten a colleague and wrote false public comments at a previous city council meeting.”

The colleague who was threatened was Councilman Michael Cacciotti and the false public comment attacked former city finance director Josh Betta, who has raised serious questions about how the city has been handling its financial reporting.

A spokesman for the Los Angeles DA’s office said, “Our office is reviewing the matter to determine whether a criminal investigation is warranted.”

Citing “relentless cyber bullying,” Khubesrian at Wednesday’s city council meeting said she was withdrawing from her three-week old bid for a third term. During a wrenching, eight-minute speech, she said “the last couple years have been really toxic on this city council and in the public. The online bullying of me and the city manager has been incredibly unfair.”

South Pasadena Police Chief Joe Ortiz told the South Pasadena News no conclusions should be drawn about the referral. He said SPPD “has done no investigation or evaluation” of the complaint. “It is quite common for law enforcement agencies to refer complaints to another law enforcement agency for their review and investigation, and that is what has happened here.”

Chris Bray, who submitted the material which the city referred to the DA, said the city’s press release understates his accusation. “What I have alleged as a possible crime is not that a councilmember sent fake public comments, though there’s very strong evidence that she has done so at least several times. What I have alleged is that a councilmember has established a pattern and practice of using false identities to attack, defame, and threaten people who criticize the city.”

His accusations were echoed in several public comments filed by citizens and read by city officials during Wednesday’s meeting before Khubesrian spoke, and included other allegations against her, as well as calls for her resignation.

Khubesrian did not directly address the accusations but said there are “social media people that are relentless in posting things that are not true and accusing me and [city manager Stephanie DeWolfe] of things that are not true.”

Khubesrian’s withdrawal from the race leaves John Donovan as the only person who has qualified to run for the seat, though the withdrawal also extends until Aug. 12, the deadline for additional candidates to file.

Khubesrian said during the Wednesday council meeting that three years ago “we hired a new city manager.” As a result, it was discovered that “our finance department was not doing proper accounting procedures and actually had some pretty old, old ways of doing things. Steps were taken in order to make the South Pasadena government a much more functional government and that for some reason has upset some people.”

Khubesrian said the past few years have been “very difficult for several of us, especially women that are on the council and [in] city management. I do believe that there is a great deal of misogyny and sexism and women are targeted in positions of leadership.” She said there needs to be a “conversation with the community” to address the problem.

The Councilmember said she’d been unfairly blamed for the treatment of Alison Smith, a resident who sued the city after sewage leaked onto her property. The city claimed the problem had to do with illegal work Smith had done at her home and sent inspectors accompanied by police to inspect her home.

Khubesrian said she had no hand in deciding how the inspection and other aspects of the case were carried out, adding “I have always recommended that they go into mediation and that the city would pay for that…I have done nothing but try to help that situation.”

“It is incredibly unfair to have this constantly be placed at my feet” by the people who raised the Smith matter in the public comments that were read before she spoke, Khubesrian said. “I am fed up with it and will not take it anymore. That’s why I am not running for city council.

“My 19-year-old daughter fears for her mother’s safety for just merely doing her job because of the relentless cyber bullying,” she said tearfully.

“I ran for city council about 10 years ago and I did it to make South Pasadena a better place. I feel very proud of the work I have done. I love this city and it pains me to see it going through this sort of phase. I’m thinking of it as growing pains. But at the end of the day, my family comes first. All three of my family members are not on board with me being on the city council anymore.”

Khubesrian said, “It is a time for us to grow. It’s a time for transformation. It’s a time for moving forward and being a better, stronger community.” She said she would serve out her term and remain engaged in city affairs, promising to make “good trouble” for the Council and community.

After Khubesrian finished, Mayor Robert Joe thanked her for her comments. Neither he nor any of the other council members reacted to her comments. The Council moved on to the next item, which was a presentation by the city manager updating the city’s COVID-19 statistics.

 

 

 

Ben Tansey is a journalist and author. He grew up in the South Bay and is a graduate of Evergreen State College. He worked in Washington State as a reporter in a rural timber community and for many years as an editor for a Western electric energy trade publication based in Seattle. He and his wife Karin, an arts administrator from El Sereno, live in South Pasadena.

5 COMMENTS

  1. In the next few years our city, South Pasadena, will face several challenging issues with the budget of great concern. We cannot afford to be distracted by personal issues between city council members or members of the public.

    As a resident of South Pasadena, a life-long Democrat and a supporter of Dr. Marina Khubesrian in her campaigns for city council it pains me to see these charges of fake emails, attacks and defamation of councilmembers and members of the public. It also causes me pain to see Councilmember Khubesrian refusing to specifically deny or admit to sending the e-mails in questions.

    The problems now facing this city must immediately be addressed. We cannot wait until the next election and (with the hope) the swearing-in of a new city council will make all this negativity disappear.

    If Councilmember Khubesrian cannot or will not defend herself, I, sadly-very sadly-believe she should immediately resign her office.

    We. Must. Move. On. The future awaits us.

  2. Well said, SoPasTiger92. Crying misogyny, sexism, racism, cyber bullying and other disparaging names about one’s critics does not address the very real problems of the city. Those like Marina Khubesrian who engaging in these deflection tactics not only are offensive and wrong, but they do a disservice to the very causes they claim to support. Marina Khubesrian is not fit to fix the toxic attitudes that she describes. She’s one of the reasons for the toxicity.

  3. Misogyny and sexism aren’t the reason for problems with the budget and financial auditing. They aren’t the reason that the former mayor is being investigated for writing fake emails and public comments. And they also aren’t the reason SoPas is having issues with retaining good employees. If the workplace culture bears any resemblance to the city council culture, I’m absolutely not surprised that there is an issue with employee turnover.

    How incredibly disingenuous of you to blame misogyny and sexism, Ms Khubesrian. And how incredibly offensive to those of us who actually HAVE experienced actual sexism and misogyny. Let me remind you….You WANTED a position of government leadership enough to pursue election to the city council for the past 10 years. With that position comes responsibility, accountability, criticism, and questioning. If you can’t handle those, then you should get out of politics and government service.

    Under the leadership of the current city council and city manager; we have seen our finances, personnel, and city management decline. We have seen public trust in our city government shaken. Pointing out the obvious is not misogynistic or sexist, so stop trying to deny responsibility for your own actions and stop shutting down input from residents and city employees that you dislike.

  4. The first and last words on justice were spoken a few years ago. They were “inclusive” of every topic, every people, and every system of governance. There ain’t a need to put a new spin on them, and there never will be.

    “Injustice anywhere is a threat to justice everywhere”